Comment · Mon, June 25, 2012

Supreme Court Strikes Down Most of Arizona Crackdown on Illegal Immigrants

What they were answering

LOLN · 1 points

You're not understanding my qualm though.

Having no documentation of citizenship on their person should not be legal grounds for arrest since the arrest then assumes guilt upon providing proof of citizenship.

The original infringement that allows them to ask for identification (name/address, not id card) doesn't have to be an arrestable offense in this case, either.

u/MisterYouAreSoDumb

Ok, I see what you are saying. A traffic offense becomes an arrestable offense due to their inability to produce proof of citizenship. However, is that not how all other offenses are handled when making an arrest? They are innocent until proven guilty, but the possibility that they violated the law gives the officer the ability to arrest them. Or am I off base?

Other MYASD lines in this thread

Related in the archive

Commentr/politicsMar 7, 2013r/Nootropics years

Six Boston cops fired after testing positive for cocaine have been ordered reinstated — with back pay

Replying to ipretendiamacat · I'm not quite sure I get this... he's just grabbing cocaine powder and stuffing it in his pocket? I don't know his cookie policy, but I'm fairly certain the drug users would be car…

I think he might be lying. Nobody puts cookies in their pants pocket.

570

Commentr/politicsSep 4, 2012r/Nootropics years

Cop claimed aggressive youth who swung at him had reached for his gun, at which point he fired his gun at the youth in self defense. Newly released surveillance footage.. shows cop running up behind the youth, then smashing him in the head with his gun in a surprise attack...

Replying to CosmicDustbunny · I used to say this, and being a middle-class white girl made me doubt I'd ever have a reason to say otherwise. Then a few years ago I got pulled over and told I had run a red ligh…

I was driving down the freeway on Thanksgiving one year, going the speed limit. There was a cop about half a mile in front of me. Suddenly he slammed on his brakes. I changed lanes and passed him, then he pulled me over.

111

Commentr/politicsJun 28, 2012r/Nootropics years

The Chicago City Council just voted 43-2 to decriminalize possession of marijuana.

Replying to slybrows · He should have said that it's already de-criminalized if you're white *in Chicago*. The cops here are pretty. fucking. racist.

All the Chicago cops are pretty? Damn!

105

Commentr/politicsSep 6, 2012r/Nootropics years

Earth’s richest 1,000 individuals now control as much wealth as the poorest 2.5 billion people on the planet. This super elite uses its vast wealth to control the media, influence politicians, and bend laws to their favor.

Replying to [deleted] · No many of them live in this country. This country is a seething shithole of an exponentially growing extreme poverty class. 46.37 million Americans live below the poverty line a…

While I agree, the poverty line here in the US is slightly higher than many countries. I've seen things in Egypt, Mexico, India, Africa etc. that are on a whole other scale.

Commentr/politicsJul 24, 2012r/Nootropics years

Aurora shooting victim could face $2 million in medical bills because of lack of health insurance

Replying to [deleted] · This. Hell, my grandfather was in the hospital after a stroke for three weeks before passing and his total bill for everything was ~$17,000,000. Yep, that's not exorbitant at all…

While I agree medical costs are out of control, I have a hard time believing that your grandfather's 3 weeks stay cost $17 million!

Commentr/politicsJul 19, 2012r/Nootropics years

Is it true? Did the baby-boomers take advantage of the social programs their parents created and cemented, then voted to dismantle those same benefits for their children in the name of freedom, individual responsibility, and more benefits for themselves? Can a generation be that selfish?

Replying to torpidnotion · The generational theory doesn't take into consideration the proliferation of technology. It's especially true that in the past 20 years, technology has shortened this cycle. Ther…

This is what I was thinking. Perhaps the cycles will shift or change entirely, given our new ability to transfer knowledge faster. Why do the cycles always have to be the same, or happen at all, regardless of innovation