Skip to content

Comment · Wed, February 26, 2020

ND edits reviews and doesn't tell you before or after you post it?

Original post in this thread

bulldog521521 · 13 points

I submitted a review for the KSM-66 capsules yesterday, and I went back to read it after it officially posted to make sure I didn't make any major typos or anything, and I noticed that a couple things were definitely changed from how I originally wrote it. Nothing big, but they changed any time I wrote the word anxiety and replaced it with anxiousness or anxious feelings about...

I'm a little concerned by this. While they didn't change anything about the overall message of my review, they did change some words and that bothers me. If they're willing to do that without disclosure, what else could they be changing on other reviews? What if they're changing certain words on negative reviews to make them less harsh? Idk. It's just sketchy.

What they were answering

baronjpetor · 21 points

I'm ND's distributor in Mexico so I'm not officially part of the team, but close enough to have an idea of why they would do this, as we had the same kind of issues in Mexico.

If you associate a supplement to a medical property (in this case for example "KSM-66 helps my anxiety"), the google algorithm will demolish the website SEO-wise (which means that the page will lose its pagerank), even if the comment was made by a customer (which is pretty dumb, but it is what it is...).

This is why ND's team would have to slightly edit some keywords that correspond to a medical condition (in this case "anxiety" is turned into "anxiousness" which isn't considered as a medical condition by the google algorithm and won't have an impact on SEO). It doesn't affect the core message of the reviews but it 's a necessity to do so if you don't want to see your website disappear from the 1st page of google's results.

I may be wrong but I think this would be the reason of the edits you saw. I'm sure MYASD will do a better job at explaining it than myself though.

u/MisterYouAreSoDumb

You were close, it was due to the disease. However, it was not due to SEO. It's entirely a legal issue.

Other MYASD lines in this thread

Related in the archive

Postr/NootropicsDepotJun 11, 2022

Lab Testing Results Of Turkesterone, Beta Ecdysterone, and Gorilla Mind Sigma

Okay, so I am finally getting around to make a post about the results of some of the lab testing we have been doing. I've had the results for a bit, but I've been holding off on officially releasing them because frankly

866436BacopaTongkat aliAshwagandha
Postr/NootropicsDepotFeb 21, 2020

⚠️🔬 Recent Industry Recalls and Safety Notices 🔬⚠️

Many of our customers have been receiving emails from Amazon and other retailers/marketplaces discussing an important product safety notification. This safety notification is in regards to a nationwide recall from a larg

15773Ashwagandha
Commentr/NootropicsDepotJun 11, 2024

Yall wanna explain dis 😂

LOL, what explanation do you want? I am doing exactly what I said I would do on the below posts. https://www.reddit.com/r/Supplements/comments/1czvlqn/consumer_labs_latest_results_for_ashwagandha_are/ https://www.reddi

127Lion’s maneAshwagandha
Commentr/NootropicsDepotJul 3, 2023

Possible Fake?

Always make sure it says "sold by Nootropics Depot" when buying from us on Amazon. We have brand protection on there, which is supposed to prevent hijacking of our listings. However, they seem to have found a way around

78AshwagandhaRhodiola
Commentr/NootropicsDepotMay 24, 2024

ConsumerLab's Ashwagandha report: KSM and Shoden

I have already reached out to our lawyers on this. I am sick of Consumer Lab ranking products using shoddy chemistry! Consumer Lab is using methods to quantify withanolides that only look at a small portion of them in th

72Lion’s maneAshwagandha
Commentr/NootropicsDepotJul 3, 2023

MisterYouAreSoDumb, what is your current stack and why? (2023)

* Infini-C * Infini-B * CoQSol-CF * Yeast Extract * D3/K2 (MK7) * EGCG * Andrographis * Epicatechin * Cistanche * Tongkat 10% * Hesperidin * Berberine Phytosome * Quercetin Phytosome * Boswellia Phytosome * NADH with Chl

69Tongkat aliCistancheAshwagandhaL-theanine