Skip to content

Comment · Wed, March 20, 2019 · Natrium Health & Nootropics Depot

Why doesn't Nootropics Depot and Real Mushrooms provide terpene % for lion's mane?

Original post in this thread

epiktek · 7 points

I've read that terpene is the compound that differentiates lion's mane from other shrooms. If so, wouldn't it be common sense to isolate this compound and make it the primary selling point?

What they were answering

Direct reply to the original post — see the thread post above.

u/MisterYouAreSoDumb · Natrium Health & Nootropics Depot

We are currently working on a lab buildout to be able to do this type of testing. The problem is a lack of validated methods and validated reference standards. Anyone can claim anything they want. Far more often than not those claims are not based in sound science, or are completely made up. Real ISO 17025 labs will not take on projects without a sound scientific basis behind the validity of their results. No legitimate lab is currently willing to quantify erinacines and hericenones in lion's mane, due to the lack of consensus on the methods and standards. Trust me, if there was one that I was confident in we would be doing it.

So where does that leave us? Well we can do all the legwork to create our own methods and standards, but that is an expensive, time-consuming, and difficult process. It also requires some very accurate and expensive machinery. This would be a UPLC and triple quad MS, or perhaps a GC-MS/MS. You would probably want to NMR to validate the identity, too. Once we have isolated and validated the identity of the erinacines and hericenones, we could then use them as reference standards to quantify them using other methodologies like HP-TLC with quantification. If Sigma or another company had reference standards we could buy, this would be a whole lot easier. Without those we have do to all the method development and validation to separate, identify, and quantify them using verified methodologies. It is something we are certainly going to do. It's just taking us some time to complete another expansion of our lab buildout, and to get the equipment necessary for us to start development of the methods. I am not going to make claims that I cannot back up with sound science. I cut a check for a UPLC last week, but the other machinery will take me some more time. A full Waters UPLC-MS/MS system retails for about $480,000.

As for other people currently making claims about the amount of erinacines and hericenones in their lion's mane, I would ask for proof. Show me the results and methods you are using to justify that claim. As it stands, there is none. It's only words and numbers on a page; words and numbers that are next to others that are complete BS if you know you are doing. However, I'm not going to get into all that at the moment. Let's just stick to the science. I ask anyone making claims about erinacines and hericenones, or total terpenes in their lion's mane product, to show me the results and methods used to reach those numbers. If they are legitimate, and based in sound science, there should be no fear in releasing those. Then we can analyze them and try to recreate the results.

Regarding selling the isolated terpenes, that could be a possibility down the line. However, they would be expensive, and they likely all work together to give the desired effects. So taking one or a few might not give all the desired effects. All the human clinical research on lion's mane has used whole fruiting body mushroom powder. So we can speculate as to what isolated compounds would do in humans, but the clinical research is all on whole mushroom powder. We can definitely postulate how they would work based off animal studies, but at the very least we need to be absolutely sure we are isolating the proper compounds. Up until this point, there are no validated and legitimate methods to do that. They are all ad-hoc in individual studies without validation. If someone has done the leg work that I don't know about, I'd welcome that science with open arms! I just need to see it.

Other MYASD lines in this thread

Related in the archive

Commentr/NootropicsFeb 24, 2021

Nootropics Depot not posting negative review

So we had to deal with some pretty big lawsuits last year. I wish I could say that is new, but I deal with half a dozen lawsuits every year. I just settled one two days ago, in fact. I have two more I am dealing with rig

475Lion’s maneCordyceps
Commentr/NootropicsJun 11, 2024

ND is lying about their in house testing

Since you are spamming this everywhere, I will put a link with my response everywhere. https://www.reddit.com/r/NootropicsDepot/comments/1ddeb2x/yall_wanna_explain_dis/l84g7mw/ [Since many people don't have access to C

66Lion’s maneAshwagandha
Commentr/NootropicsJan 28, 2020

This is part of the wholesale price list for "Nammex", the supplier of mushroom powders that many companies repackage/encapsulate and sell for a huge profit margin

Replying to eclecticlove1 · So where do you get the powder for the 8:1 dual phase extract?

We have our own suppliers, just like we do for all our ND branded products. They make it to our specifications. Then we test them in our lab for ID, content, beta-glucans, heavy metals, and now residual solvent residues.

40Lion’s mane
Commentr/NootropicsApr 27, 2017

Why the lion's mane you're buying is probably bunk.

First off, our Lion's Mane is not a traditional water extract. The water is used to break down the chitin in the cell walls, but the entire mushroom material is kept in. So you don't lose anything that you would with a f

35Lion’s mane
Commentr/NootropicsDepotMar 12, 2025

Is ND done launching new products?

We are absolutely NOT done with new products. We are in the thick of development for a bunch of them. Some of them are just taking longer than expected to get perfect, so we have had a lull in releases. That's just becau

147Lion’s maneTongkat ali
Commentr/NootropicsAug 28, 2023

new research on the lion's mane

Replying to GeauxTiger · Maybe Im missing a step here, so this is specifically about hericene A, a compound in lions mane. But how much? How much hericene is there, they tested at 250mg, if Im taking 2gm o

It's talking about N-de phenylethyl isohericerin (NDPIH) and hericene A. You are not getting much of either in most lion's mane products. You have to grow specific strains in a specific way to get high levels of these ac

29Lion’s mane