Comment · Sat, August 1, 2026 · ND Owner

Why the difference in reviews on Reddit vs. Amazon for MicroMag?

Original post in this thread

Lesliefourwinds · 7 points

Looking into sucrasomial magnesium and reddit raves about MicroMag yet the Amazon reviews list quite a few people saying it didn’t work for them digestively. The bad reviews are more than most other magnesium products. Yet far and wide it seems to be the most recommended brand for Sucrasomial. There are some other brands that got better reviews for Sucrasomial magnesium (Legion, Pure E) but yet I’ve heard more people praise Nootropics than the others. Anyone want to chime in on this?

What they were answering

CaptainExcellent5299 · 1 points

I believe the sale to Nestle was almost 10 years ago? The biggest issue seems to be the outrageous cost of some products. I haven’t noticed any quality or potency issues with their products. The UltraMag is the only example I’m aware of where the branded ingredient is no longer listed. I’ve never tried it before or after.

u/MisterYouAreSoDumb · ND Owner

It was 9 years ago, but yeah. It's been Nestle for a while. They have sucked for a while. They always fail our testing. Our most recent test of theirs was their Ashwagandha. They claimed 12.5mg withanolides per capsule. We found 1.49mg per capsule, so a massive failure. That was just the most recent.

Other MYASD lines in this thread

Related in the archive

Postr/NootropicsDepotJun 11, 2022Nootropics DepotND Owner

Lab Testing Results Of Turkesterone, Beta Ecdysterone, and Gorilla Mind Sigma

Okay, so I am finally getting around to make a post about the results of some of the lab testing we have been doing. I've had the results for a bit, but I've been holding off on officially releasing them because frankly

866436BacopaTongkat aliAshwagandha

Postr/NootropicsDepotFeb 21, 2020Nootropics Depot

⚠️🔬 Recent Industry Recalls and Safety Notices 🔬⚠️

Many of our customers have been receiving emails from Amazon and other retailers/marketplaces discussing an important product safety notification. This safety notification is in regards to a nationwide recall from a larg

15773Ashwagandha

Commentr/NootropicsDepotJun 11, 2024Enforcement & pleaND Owner

Yall wanna explain dis 😂

LOL, what explanation do you want? I am doing exactly what I said I would do on the below posts. https://www.reddit.com/r/Supplements/comments/1czvlqn/consumer_labs_latest_results_for_ashwagandha_are/ https://www.reddi

127Lion’s maneAshwagandha

Commentr/NootropicsDepotJul 3, 2023Enforcement & pleaND Owner

Possible Fake?

Always make sure it says "sold by Nootropics Depot" when buying from us on Amazon. We have brand protection on there, which is supposed to prevent hijacking of our listings. However, they seem to have found a way around

78AshwagandhaRhodiola

Commentr/NootropicsDepotMay 24, 2024Enforcement & pleaND Owner

ConsumerLab's Ashwagandha report: KSM and Shoden

I have already reached out to our lawyers on this. I am sick of Consumer Lab ranking products using shoddy chemistry! Consumer Lab is using methods to quantify withanolides that only look at a small portion of them in th

72Lion’s maneAshwagandha

Commentr/NootropicsDepotJul 3, 2023Enforcement & pleaND Owner

MisterYouAreSoDumb, what is your current stack and why? (2023)

* Infini-C * Infini-B * CoQSol-CF * Yeast Extract * D3/K2 (MK7) * EGCG * Andrographis * Epicatechin * Cistanche * Tongkat 10% * Hesperidin * Berberine Phytosome * Quercetin Phytosome * Boswellia Phytosome * NADH with Chl

69Tongkat aliCistancheAshwagandhaL-theanine