Skip to content

Comment · Wed, March 13, 2019

Questions about "The Top 5 Milk Thistle Health Benefits" blog!

Original post in this thread

ar-jan · 1 points

I enjoyed the article. And I have a few questions!

1) Can you clarify: better to take milk thistle before or after alcohol use?

Article says "it appears that one of the positive effects of milk thistle supplementation before alcohol consumption is hangover support."

But later: "it may be smart to utilize a milk thistle liver cleanse, especially after alcohol consumption to utilize the milk thistle hangover prevention effects."

2) For liver support in general, do you think taking milk thistle a particular time of day would be helpful or important, given that liver function has a strong circadian rhythm?

What they were answering

Direct reply to the original post — see the thread post above.

u/MisterYouAreSoDumb

1) Milk thistle is not one that is super dependent on timing for dosing. You can take it before or after drinking. It will provide the best results when taken before drinking, though.

2) The liver's cycles are both dependent on your circadian rhythm and your eating/fasting state. So it depends on your specific situation. I fast all day till the evening, so my cycle is going to be different than someone eating three meals. Either way, I would say taking milk thistle in the morning is probably the best idea. Perhaps taking a second dose later in the day would be a good idea as well.

Related in the archive

Commentr/NootropicsDepotDec 22, 2025

Alcohol Question - Supplements to Prevent the Damage?

Replying to mbvlover25 · NAC, Milk Thistle & Tudca

You have to be really careful with TUDCA and alcohol. Let me break this down, as there's a lot of confusion around TUDCA and alcohol timing. Many companies say that you should avoid TUDCA within 24 hours of consuming alc

16DosingMilk thistle
Commentr/NootropicsDepotJun 21, 2020

Capsule request: Carnosine and Milk Thistle

We have berberine and milk thistle coated tablets in production now. We are also about to do standalone milk thistle/silymarin capsules. The issue is that everyone is saying their milk thistle is 80% silymarins, but it i

9COADosingMilk thistle
Commentr/NootropicsJun 30, 2020

Safe to Buy Now Food Supplements from Amazon?

Replying to [deleted] · [deleted]

Okay, scratch what I said. I just got some lab results back from NOW's milk thistle, and it failed our testing. It is only 70% of label claim! I literally bought NOW, Jarrow, and Life Extension in this test as our positi

45DosingMilk thistle
Commentr/NootropicsDepotOct 27, 2020

u/MisterYouAreSoDumb which product(s) are you most proud of?

Replying to DrBobMaui · Much thanks for the reply! I started getting ear damage from loud noises from working in the steel mills starting at age 12 (61 yrs ago) ... that was before hearing protection ...

I found a few things that might be of interest. [Red ginseng protects against gentamicin-induced balance dysfunction and hearing loss in rats through antiapoptotic functions of ginsenoside Rb1](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.n

6DosingGinsengMilk thistle
Commentr/NootropicsDepotJul 30, 2025

⚠️ NEW PRODUCT RELEASES ARE COMING 07/31/25 | Three Mystery Products, Mushroom Magic Magic Powder Blend, Mushroom Magic Advanced Powder Blend & TUDCA⚠️

Replying to Warm_Ad_6177 · There was an in vitro study with human liver cells that concluded that pre-treatment with TUDCA markedly increased cell damage by alcohol, though there were benefits through a diff

I actually wrote a pretty good overview of the issue with TUDCA and alcohol. https://reddit.com/r/NootropicsDepot/comments/1ipimsj/milk_thistle_is_beneficial_to_the_liver_fact_or/mcyj7jp/

5COADosingMilk thistle
Commentr/NootropicsDepotJul 23, 2023

Could someone help me understand how ND Berberine compares to Thorne's Berberine?

Replying to SnackyFace · Very interesting, thanks for the feedback! Would it be safer to say the ND Berberine/Silymarin is more effective than the ND Phytosome, but the ND Phytosome is better tolerated by

I wouldn't say more effective. I would say the phytosome smooths out the absorption of it, allowing for less dosing. The berberine HCL/Silymarin you really take 3X per day. You can do 1-2X per day of the phytosome, as it

5DosingMilk thistle