Comment · Thu, September 18, 2025 · ND Owner
Is Red Reishi 9% and Lucidimax worth the cost when Lucidispore offers more ganoderic acids for less?
Original post in this thread
DoctorBoneMarrow · 9 points
I took some info from this thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/NootropicsDepot/comments/1me780g/new\_products\_alert\_cyatherm\_capsules\_lucidimax/
* Lucidispore (30ml): A minimum of 9g (total) of ganoderic acids for $59.99.
* Red Reishi 9% (180 caps): A minimum of 2.43g (total) of ganoderic acids for $99.99.
* Lucidimax (60 servings/120 caps): A minimum of 1.32g (total) of ganoderic acids for $69.99.
I understand ganoderic acids aren't the whole picture when it comes to Reishi and that you miss out on the immune-enhancing benefits of the beta-glucans from the fruiting bodies. However even accounting for that, the difference in price is enormous.
I can buy Lucidispore and address the immune support aspect separately with something like Turkey Tail, and the total cost per mg of ganoderic acids would still be much lower than buying Red Reishi 9% or Lucidimax. I could even buy Immune Defense, which also contains Reishi, take just a half-serving alongisde Lucidispore, and Lucidimax would still be more expensive.
**A. Lucidispore (portioned…
What they were answering
DoctorBoneMarrow · 3 points
The bulk of the human clinical research on reishi is on the fruiting bodies, and the ganoderic acids found in them.
Don't make the mistake of conflating beta-glucans as a single closely-related grouping of compounds that all do the same thing in every species.
I was conflating ganoderic acids with each other, not beta-glucans! I didn't know most research is on the fruiting bodies and that the ganoderic acids of the spores are not the same. Is it known how similar spore-derived vs fruiting body-derived ganoderic acids are? Or is this something not currently measurable due to a lack of reference standards?
Regarding the beta-glucans of Reishi, I've only seen them mentioned for immune and cholesterol benefits. I know beta-glucans don't do all the same thing, my thought process in the post was about the value proposition: do the beta-glucans in Reishi justify a much lower quantity of triterpenes for the price? If I want a mushroom to boost the immune system I can buy Turkey Tail instead, and if I want a prebiotic I can go with Poria. I don't discount that the beta-glucans of Reishi may be special in some way but I haven't seen anything remarkable that makes them stand out over other mushroom beta-glucans.
Apart from beta-glucans, do the fruiting bodies contain anything interesting that we know of, like the hericenones in Lion's Mane?
Lucidimax is the most comprehensive Reis…
u/MisterYouAreSoDumb · ND Owner
Is it known how similar spore-derived vs fruiting body-derived ganoderic acids are? Or is this something not currently measurable due to a lack of reference standards?
Not currently elucidated, but something we are working on.
Regarding the beta-glucans of Reishi, I've only seen them mentioned for immune and cholesterol benefits. I know beta-glucans don't do all the same thing, my thought process in the post was about the value proposition: do the beta-glucans in Reishi justify a much lower quantity of triterpenes for the price? If I want a mushroom to boost the immune system I can buy Turkey Tail instead, and if I want a prebiotic I can go with Poria. I don't discount that the beta-glucans of Reishi may be special in some way but I haven't seen anything remarkable that makes them stand out over other mushroom beta-glucans.
That's a more complex answer. Generally, the immune and cholesterol benefits are the most talked about with beta-glucans. However, beta-glucans are a type of prebiotic fiber that feed various probiotics. Different probiotic strains feed on different beta-glucans. Consuming more of one type over another can tip the balance of the microbiome towards those strains. If those strains produce different types of metabolites, the effects you get from them can vary. Think of beta-glucans like a prebiotic for the most part. Different prebiotics will have different effects, even though they are all prebiotics. Same concept with the beta-glucans from mushrooms.
Lucidimax is the most comprehensive Reishi product, but I struggle to see what makes it special compared to other synergistic Natrium products such as Cistamax, where the 1:1 Cistanche is an interesting prebiotic and enhances the bioavailabiliy of the ultra-potent Cistanche, while the CO2 extract has "something" that adds a distinct mood-boosting effect.
I would argue Lucidimax is more special. Cistamax only uses extract of the stem of Cistanche. They are different types of extracts, but they are all of the stem. Lucidimax uses the spores of reishi, with a patented process to crack them open, but keep all the bioactives intact. Then it uses two fruiting body reishis, one of them being a 40% beta-glucan 1:1 powder, and the other being the most potent ganoderic acid extract in the world. Then we also use sodium caprate as an absorption enhancer, so the reishi bioactives can enter the body better. If that ain't special, I am not sure what else you would want us to do with reishi. We could have pulled in some stuff from other plants and mushrooms, but we really wanted this one to just be all reishi, and let it shine on its own.
I've read a comment from u/Pretty-Chill where he says that the full serving of Lucidimax feels more relaxing than Lucidispore. If there's a synergy between the different extracts like in Cistamax then it's much more interesting, but maybe the stronger effects are just caused by the sodium caprate enhancing absorption.
There is a synergy. That's why we formulated it the way we did. There are unique effects to each reishi extract, and they are more than the sum of their parts when taken together. Sure, you could buy our 9%, 1:1, and Lucidispore separately, and take them at the same time. However, you can do that with the ingredients in Cistamax as well. We are unique in that we don't just sell stacks, but give people the freedom to buy the individual components if they want
Do you also get a stronger acute effect from Lucidimax compared with Lucidispore?
Yes, I find it stronger. Lucidispore is more one-sided. It's great for sleep, but that's mostly what I feel with it. Lucidimax gives me more comprehensive mood effects, so I use it more during the daytime.
I've been thinking this whole time that Lucidispore was standardized to ganoderic acids, but I checked again and it's 30% triterpenes. How much of that 30% can be estimated to be ganoderic acids?
Zero, at least not the ganoderic acids in the USP monograph. The triterpenes in the spores are more like ganosporelactone A/B, ganodermonotriol, ganodermondiol, and lucidumol A/B. This is what I mean by the combination is unique. The compounds the spores of reishi are not found in the fruiting body, and vice verse. It's similar to lion's mane, where we have to use the mycelium for the erinacines, and then the fruiting body for the hericenes/hericenones.