Skip to content

Comment · Thu, October 5, 2017 · Ceretropic & Nootropics Depot

Why are supplements not regulated?

Original post in this thread

bangbangIshotmyself · 0 points

Hi,

Why aren't supplements regulated by the FDA? It seems to me, with more news of people overdosing on supplements and dying due to imoure supplements, that they should be regulated by something. As a fact nearly every supplement we take is a drug, the rest are food. Just bacuse they are present in leaves and maybe ingested through tea instead of a pill(though many supplements are now in pills) doesn't mean it isn't a drug.

Assuming you agree, what can we do about this? I understand the industry is kinda sorting itself with third party tsting and people trying to only support clean brands, but it isn't fully working. It still obviously needs some degree of regulation. How would you think we could achieve that? Any way to get a bill into congress? Any ideas? (Obviously this is written about the USA in mind, other countries should regulate supplements as well, I just don't know as much about their regulatory agencies nor their government)

What they were answering

Direct reply to the original post — see the thread post above.

u/MisterYouAreSoDumb · Ceretropic & Nootropics Depot

with more news of people overdosing on supplements and dying due to imoure supplements, that they should be regulated by something.

There are ZERO reported cases of death from dietary supplements each year in the United States. ZERO

2015 Annual Report of the American Association of Poison Control Centers'. National Poison Data System \(NPDS\)

Page 1080 and 1081. They have not posted 2016 yet, but you can look back at 2014 as well.

2014 Annual Report of the American Association of Poison Control Centers’ National Poison Data System \(NPDS\)

Or 2013...

2013 Annual Report of the American Association of Poison Control Centers’ National Poison Data System \\(NPDS\\)

None. Zero deaths from dietary supplements reported by the American Association of Poison Control Centers. However, there are 128,000 deaths reported each year due to prescription drugs, and that's FDA regulated. Also, the FDA certainly does regulate the supplement industry. There are hundreds of rules that need to be followed. They just do not regulate it as crazily as they do the drug industry. Why would we want the government to step in and increase regulation in an industry that kills zero people every year, just to make it more like an industry that kills over 128,000?!?

Related in the archive

Postr/NootropicsJul 18, 2023

Independent Lab Testing Results Of Supplements On The Market

Hey everyone, it's been a while since I have made a post in this sub. However, I saw a new research study today that I wanted to bring up. It highlights why my main mission over the past 10 years has been to not only adv

402152Dosing
Postr/NootropicsNov 27, 2013

Cerebral Health Pyritinol (New Test Results)

We have finally identified the substance that Cerebral Health was selling as pyritinol, which has sent one person to the hospital, and caused adverse reactions in half a dozen other people so far. The results are very su

13776Dosing
Postr/NootropicsFeb 28, 2013

Reddit Placebo Blinded Racetam Study

Well the time has finally come. My curiosity has finally expanded to real world effectiveness, not just pharmacological mechanisms. We are all aware of the countless anecdotes for the various nootropics out there. Many o

121166PiracetamAniracetamDosingRacetams
Commentr/DrugsNov 8, 2012

Research Suggests no Neurotoxicity in MDMA

**I'm going to copy what I wrote on another thread:** _____________________________________________________ YES! Keep your damn body temperatures down people! http://www.maps.org/publications/1998_malberg_1.pdf http:

597PiracetamMagnesiumQuercetinDosing
Commentr/NootropicsNov 19, 2014

My experiences with high dose (100mg+) tianeptine over a two month period

You need to start tapering off it now! You are not using it properly, and are going to cause yourself harm. Tianeptine is hard on the liver at those dosages. It is not meant to be taken at 650mg/day. Your usage is irresp

51TianeptineDosing
Commentr/NootropicsJun 30, 2020

Safe to Buy Now Food Supplements from Amazon?

Replying to [deleted] · [deleted]

Okay, scratch what I said. I just got some lab results back from NOW's milk thistle, and it failed our testing. It is only 70% of label claim! I literally bought NOW, Jarrow, and Life Extension in this test as our positi

45DosingMilk thistle